Directions for optimizing the therapy of bronchial asthma and status asthmaticus based on cross-sectional analysis of real-world data (RWD) from National Health Fund (NFZ) and Social Insurance Institution (ZUS)
-
Copyright
© 2025 PRO MEDICINA Foundation, Published by PRO MEDICINA Foundation
User License
The journal provides published content under the terms of the Creative Commons 4.0 Attribution-International Non-Commercial Use (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.
Authors
Name | Affiliation | |
---|---|---|
Jakub Gierczyński |
European Health Network |
|
Andrzej Śliwczyński |
POLON Scientific Data Administrator, Head of the Patient Service Department, Medical Institute of the Ministry of Interior and Administration, National Research Institute |
|
Karina Jahnz-Różyk |
Head of the Clinic of Internal Medicine, Pneumonology, Allergology, Clinical Immunology and Rare Diseases, Military Institute of Medicine, National Research Institute |
Objectives
The aim is to analyse the health and
systemic effects of effective therapy for bronchial asthma and status
asthmaticus in Poland for the purpose of assessing the possibility of
introducing a model of coordinated care for patients with bronchial asthma and analysing
the limitations resulting from the introduction of a coordinated care model.
Methods
The analysis was carried out based on
actual data from the National Health Fund (NFZ) from 2013-2023 in the scope of
the medical problem of bronchial asthma, defined by the codes of the main
diagnosis ICD-10: asthma J45 and status asthmaticus J46.
Results
After the introduction of the first
medicinal products for financing under the drug program for asthma treatment in
2013, a decrease in the number of patients registered for hospital treatment
was observed at the level of: -2.79%, including, negative dynamics are observed
in AOS and POZ. This means better disease control in patients, this conclusion
is confirmedy the stable and maintained similar level of the distribution of
the number of patients, taking into account the mode of admission to the
hospital.
Conclusions
The introduction of the drug program
for the treatment of bronchial asthma and the financing of medicinal product
reduces the number of hospitalizations. After the introduction of the drug
program, the number of benefits provided for incapacity for work due to
bronchial asthma and the number of medical certificates have remained at a
constant level. The number of days of sickness absence due to bronchial asthma
has decreased.
1. Introduction
Bronchial asthma is a chronic, heterogeneous inflammatory disease of the respiratory tract [1]. The disease affects over 350 million patients worldwide. Modern care for patients with bronchial asthma is managed dynamically, using modern technologies, molecular biology and care integration. Therapeutic success requires active patient participation and close interdisciplinary cooperation, and coordinated care becomes the key to effective treatment. According to GINA 2024, the modern approach to the diagnosis and treatment of asthma involves a transition from symptomatic treatment to a personalized and proactive strategy[2]. It is recommended to avoid monotherapy with short-acting inhaled β2-agonists (SABA), such as salbutamol or fenoterol. The preferred treatment regimen is inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) plus formoterol as needed, starting from the lowest degree of asthma severity. It is recommended to gradually treat bronchial asthma:
- Step 1–2: inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) + formoterol as needed
- Step 3–4: inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) + long-acting inhaled β2-agonists (LABA) + long-acting anticholinergics (LAMA) on a regular schedule
- Step 5: biological therapy, systemic glucocorticosteroids (GCS), as a last resort
As part of biological
treatment in the drug program B.44 Treatment of patients with severe asthma,
the following drugs are currently reimbursed: Omalizumab (anti-IgE - allergic
phenotype), Mepolizumab and Benralizumab (anti-IL-5 - eosinophilia), Dupilumab
(anti-IL-4/13) and Tezepelumab (independent of the level of eosinophilia). The
effects of biological treatment include a reduction in exacerbations,
improvement in lung function and a reduction in the dose of
glucocorticosteroids (GCS). In the years 2016-2024, the number of patients
treated in the drug program B.44 Treatment of patients with severe asthma
increased, from 438 people in 2016 to 3,457 people in 2023 and 4,729 people in
2024. In 2024, the largest number of patients in the drug program B.44 Treatment
of patients with severe asthma were treated with: benralizumab - 1,554
patients, then mepolizumab - 1,398 patients, omalizumab - 718 patients,
dupilumab - 597 patients and tezepelumab - 462 patients. Patients were treated
in 69 clinical centers implementing the B.44 drug program. In 2024, the
National Health Fund allocated PLN 183,477,537 in total for contracts for the
B.44 Treatment of patients with severe asthma drug program, of which PLN
158,813,984 for active substances and PLN 24,663,553 for medical services. The
National Health Fund's expenditures under contracts for drug programs in 2024
amounted to PLN 12.8 billion, i.e. the B.44 drug program accounted for 1.4% of
total expenditures for drug programs.
The effects of coordinated
care for patients with bronchial asthma include a reduction in disease
exacerbations and hospitalizations, better matching of therapy to the patient's
needs, higher levels of satisfaction and adherence to recommendations, and the
possibility of early detection of deterioration of health. Challenges and
directions of development of coordinated care for patients with bronchial
asthma in Poland include reimbursement availability of biological therapies,
integrated registers and data systems (including registers of patients with
asthma and collection of real data (RWE) in order to optimize therapy, and
psychological and rehabilitation support for the patient.
An element of the
implementation of these assumptions is the preparation of the following report,
by collecting actual data (RWE) from the resources of the National Health Fund
and the Social Insurance Institution and analyzing the health and systemic
effects of effective therapy for bronchial asthma and status asthmaticus in
Poland in recent years.
2. Materials and methods
Data
were obtained from the National Health Fund (NHF) from the years 2013-2023 (at
the time of data generation by the NHF, the year 2024 was not yet available)
regarding the medical problem of bronchial asthma, defined by the main
diagnosis codes ICD-10: asthma J45 (entire group) and status asthmaticus J46
(entire group) [3]. The data received were depersonalized and
aggregated by the NHF, maintaining the principles of protection of particularly
sensitive data. A retrospective analysis of the dynamics of asthma morbidity in
the Polish population in several organizational cross-sections was performed on
the obtained data set. Results were obtained for the entire population with
treated asthma and for the population treated under the drug program. The
number of patients and the number of reported health services were analyzed.
Results were obtained for:
1. Number of patients, including:
- number of patients treated in the main segments of healthcare, i.e. hospital care, outpatient specialist care, primary health care;
- dynamics of the number of patients in the above types of services year/year and in the periods before the pandemic (2019-2013) and after the pandemic (2023-2019) and in the entire analyzed period (2033-2013)
2. Number of health services provided in each main type of service
3. Patient admission mode into categories: urgent mode and stable mode.
Data were obtained from the Social Insurance Institution (SII) from the years 2019-2023 (at the time of data generation by SII, the year 2024 was not yet available) in the scope of the statistics of SII benefits for incapacity for work resulting from the medical problem of bronchial asthma, defined by the codes of the main diagnosis ICD-10: asthma J45 (the entire group) and status asthmaticus J46 (the entire group). An analysis was made of the number and value of reported benefits[4]. Results were obtained for:
- Benefit values for disability pensions, social pensions, sickness absence, rehabilitation benefits and medical rehabilitation for bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46).
- The number of persons insured with ZUS who were issued a medical certificate for bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) at least once in the years 2019-2024.
- Number of sick leave days due to bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) in 2012-2024.
3. Results
Services provided with a
diagnosis of asthma settled by the National Health Fund in the years 2013-2023
In
the years 2013-2019, the number of patients diagnosed with ICD-10 J45 Bronchial
asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus remained at a
stable level - an average of 1,100 thousand patients. In the years 2020-2021,
the number of patients with the diagnosis was less than 1,100 thousand patients
and increased again in the years 2022-2023. The largest number of patients with
the diagnosis of ICD-10 J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and
J46 Status asthmaticus was observed in the years 2013-2023 at the level of
Ambulatory Specialist Care (AOS), then at the level of Primary Health Care, and
the fewest patients with the diagnosis occurred in hospital treatment.
In
2020, the largest change was observed in the number of patients diagnosed with
ICD-10 J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status
asthmaticus at any level of care compared to the number of patients in the
previous year. Within Specialist Outpatient Care, the number of patients
decreased by 14% compared to the previous year. Within Primary Health Care,
also by 14%, while within hospital treatment, the number of patients decreased
by as much as 42% year-on-year (Figure 1), (Table 1, Table 2).
Figure 1. Number of patients with ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Table 1. Number of patients with ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Year |
Poland |
Hospital care |
Outpatient Specialist care |
Primary Health Care |
2013 |
1169.35 |
45.13 |
759.59 |
675.21 |
2014 |
1176.88 |
44.46 |
755.74 |
676.4 |
2015 |
1185.75 |
44.35 |
753.1 |
690.62 |
2016 |
1173.05 |
42.63 |
740.39 |
678.08 |
2017 |
1161.29 |
42.42 |
728.38 |
666.52 |
2018 |
1127.78 |
40.93 |
712.15 |
635.66 |
2019 |
1113.69 |
40 |
702.06 |
627.14 |
2020 |
972.13 |
22.86 |
597.96 |
537.84 |
2021 |
983.12 |
22.95 |
585.83 |
565.41 |
2022 |
1023.83 |
31.18 |
607.99 |
595.31 |
2023 |
1071.13 |
34.39 |
638.4 |
634.07 |
Table 2. Dynamics of the number of patients with the diagnosis ICD-10 J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus year on year in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Detail, comparison |
Poland |
Hospital care |
Outpatient Specialist care |
Primary Health Care |
2014/2013 |
0.64% |
-1.48% |
-0.51% |
0.18% |
2015/2014 |
0.75% |
-0.25% |
-0.35% |
2.10% |
2016/2015 |
-1.07% |
-3.88% |
-1.69% |
-1.82% |
2017/2016 |
-1.00% |
-0.49% |
-1.62% |
-1.70% |
2018/2017 |
-2.89% |
-3.51% |
-2.23% |
-4.63% |
2019/2018 |
-1.25% |
-2.27% |
-1.42% |
-1.34% |
average
2019-2013 |
-0.81% |
-1.99% |
-1.30% |
-1.22% |
2020/2019 |
-12.71% |
-42.85% |
-14.83% |
-14.24% |
2021/2020 |
1.13% |
0.39% |
-2.03% |
5.13% |
2022/2021 |
4.14% |
35.86% |
3.78% |
5.29% |
2023/2022 |
4.62% |
10.30% |
5.00% |
6.51% |
average
2023-2019 |
-0.97% |
-3.71% |
-2.35% |
0.28% |
average 2023-2013 |
-0.87% |
-2.68% |
-1.72% |
-0.63% |
The number of services provided
with the diagnosis ICD-10 J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes
and J46 Status asthmaticus has been systematically decreasing since 2013. In
2013, the total number of services provided amounted to 3750.49 thousand. In
2018, the number of such services amounted to 3146.96 thousand. In 2020, the
number of services provided decreased by 12% compared to the previous year. In
2023, it amounted to 2854.92 thousand.
In the years covered by the
analysis, the largest number of services were provided as part of outpatient
specialist care - 2125.26 thousand services in 2013, 1778.47 thousand in 2018
and 1467.43 thousand in 2023. The next in line in terms of the number of
services provided is Primary Health Care – 1,545.67 thousand services in 2013,
1,286.29 thousand services in 2018 and 1,467.43 thousand in 2023. The fewest
services were provided as part of hospital care – less than 50 thousand
services each year, with the largest reduction in the number of services
provided observed in 2020 – by as much as 45% compared to the previous year. On
average, in the years 2013-2023, the number of services provided decreased by
2.69% (Figure 2), (Table 3, Table 4).
Table 3. Number of services provided with the ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus in the years 2013-2023, thou
Year |
Poland |
Hospital |
Outpatient Specialist care |
Primary Health Care |
2013 |
3750.49 |
45.68 |
2125.26 |
1545.67 |
2014 |
3685.69 |
44.75 |
2087.68 |
1520.51 |
2015 |
3588.77 |
44.36 |
2006.58 |
1508.02 |
2016 |
3472.99 |
42.75 |
1942.25 |
1453.27 |
2017 |
3333.82 |
42.25 |
1856.01 |
1396.68 |
2018 |
3146.96 |
40.53 |
1778.47 |
1286.29 |
2019 |
3036 |
39.8 |
1702.85 |
1248.69 |
2020 |
2538.59 |
21.56 |
1447.77 |
1038.87 |
2021 |
2567.67 |
22 |
1421.75 |
1091.78 |
2022 |
2637.82 |
30.07 |
1411.57 |
1158.72 |
2023 |
2854.92 |
34.42 |
1467.43 |
1305.11 |
Table 4. Dynamics of the number of services provided with the ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus year on year in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Detail,
comparison |
Poland |
Hospital |
Outpatient
Specialist care |
Primary
Health Care |
2014/2013 |
-1.73% |
-2.04% |
-1.77% |
-1.63% |
2015/2014 |
-2.63% |
-0.87% |
-3.88% |
-0.82% |
2016/2015 |
-3.23% |
-3.63% |
-3.21% |
-3.63% |
2017/2016 |
-4.01% |
-1.17% |
-4.44% |
-3.89% |
2018/2017 |
-5.60% |
-4.07% |
-4.18% |
-7.90% |
2019/2018 |
-3.53% |
-1.80% |
-4.25% |
-2.92% |
average 2019-2013 |
-3.46% |
-2.27% |
-3.63% |
-3.49% |
2020/2019 |
-16.38% |
-45.83% |
-14.98% |
-16.80% |
2021/2020 |
1.15% |
2.04% |
-1.80% |
5.09% |
2022/2021 |
2.73% |
36.68% |
-0.72% |
6.13% |
2023/2022 |
8.23% |
14.47% |
3.96% |
12.63% |
average 2023-2019 |
-1.53% |
-3.57% |
-3.65% |
1.11% |
average
2023-2013 |
-2.69% |
-2.79% |
-3.64% |
-1.68% |
Analyzing
the course of variables, a serious decrease in the number of patients and
services provided was observed during the pandemic period, with the highest
decreases in hospital treatment. These decreases are balanced by dynamic
increases in the number of patients and services in the drug program. The
implementation of services in the drug program additionally confirms the
decrease in services provided as part of hospitalization.
Analysis
of the dynamics of variability for both the number of patients and the number
of services provided is quite similar. Assessing the compliance of average
rates, the values of the convergence
index (correlation coefficient) in individual periods were obtained in terms of
the module in the range of 0.49-0.99. The periods 2018-2019, 2013-2019, where
the analyzed categories were practically non-convergent, and the period
2014-2015, where the relationship of the analyzed changes is very low, which is
also visible from the course of the dynamics.
In the years 2013-2023, the average number of patients and the number of services provided decreased year by year, both in total and by place of service provision: Specialist Outpatient Care, Primary Health Care and hospital (Table 5).
Table 5. Correlation coefficient of changes in the number of services provided and the number of patients with ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus in the years 2013-2023
Period |
Coefficient
ρ |
2014/2013 |
0.87 |
2015/2014 |
0.49 |
2016/2015 |
0.69 |
2017/2016 |
0.84 |
2018/2017 |
0.78 |
2019/2018 |
- 0.80 |
average 2019-2013 |
- 0.85 |
2020/2019 |
0.99 |
2021/2020 |
0.96 |
2022/2021 |
0.99 |
2023/2022 |
0.80 |
average 2023-2019 |
0.93 |
Average
2023-2013 |
0.54 |
The largest number of hospitalizations with the diagnosis ICD-10 J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus of adult patients, excluding hospitalizations under the drug program and hospitalizations started and ended on the same day, were provided as part of emergency admissions. In 2013, the number of such hospitalizations amounted to 16.27 thousand, in 2018 it decreased to 14.27 thousand, and in 2023 it amounted to 8.8 thousand. In turn, the number of hospitalizations due to planned admissions amounted to 10.83 thousand in 2013, 9.35 thousand in 2018 and 7.46 thousand in 2023 (Table 6).
Table 6. Number of hospitalisations in inpatient treatment with the ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus of adult patients, excluding hospitalisations under a drug programme and hospitalisations started and ended on the same day, broken down by admission mode in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Year |
Emergency
admissions |
Planned
receptions |
2013 |
16.27 |
10.83 |
2014 |
16.05 |
10.67 |
2015 |
16.45 |
10.13 |
2016 |
15.43 |
9.84 |
2017 |
15.48 |
9.82 |
2018 |
14.27 |
9.35 |
2019 |
13.06 |
9.15 |
2020 |
6.89 |
4.42 |
2021 |
5.48 |
4.18 |
2022 |
7.72 |
6.21 |
2023 |
8.8 |
7.46 |
If not for the pandemic, the course would be practically linear with a decreasing trend. In its current form, the course of the curves can be described by a trend function in the form of a polynomial of degree 3 or higher. In the final periods of observation, an upward trend is noticeable in all types of admissions, which would indicate a return of the phenomenon to the level before the pandemic period (Figure 3), (Table 7)
Figure
3. Comparison of the time courses - the number of hospitalizations in inpatient
treatment with the ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic
causes and J46 Status asthmaticus of adult patients excluding hospitalizations
under the drug program and hospitalizations started and ended on the same day,
broken down by admission mode in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Table 7. Trend function in the form of a polynomial of degree 3 for the change in the time courses of the number of hospitalizations in hospital treatment with the ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus
Emergency admissions |
Planned receptions |
t= 1.….11.
Comparing the share of emergency admissions to the share of planned admissions, this ratio oscillates around 40% to 60%, with a noticeable increase in the share of planned admissions and a decrease in emergency admissions, which indicates an increase in patient safety and a decrease in the number of sudden disease events, which is assessed positively in the long term (Figure 4).
Figure
4. Relationship between the share of emergency admissions and the share of
planned admissions with the ICD-10 diagnosis J45 Bronchial asthma mainly due to
allergic causes and J46 Status asthmaticus of adult patients, excluding
hospitalizations under the drug program and hospitalizations started and ended
on the same day, broken down by admission mode in the years 2013-2023
The
simulation models below allow for the assessment of the consequences of
treating a given group of patients and provide the possibility of potential
transfers of patients from Specialist Outpatient Care to hospital treatment and
vice versa. If, for example, 10 patients were transferred from Specialist
Outpatient Care to hospital treatment, this would result in a decrease of 1
patient in emergency admissions and an increase of almost 3 patients in planned
admissions.
Simulation model:
Emergency admissions
Planned admissions
Drug program B.44 Treatment of
patients with severe asthma
Number of patients in the drug program B.44 Treatment of
patients with severe asthma
Under
the B.44 Treatment of patients with severe asthma drug program, the number of
patients under treatment increased year by year in the years 2013-2023. In
2013, the number of patients in the drug program was 247 people. In 2018, this
number increased to 764 people. In 2019, the number of patients under treatment
increased by as much as 41% compared to the previous year. In 2013, the number
of patients in the drug program was 3,426. The average rate of increase in the
number of patients in the drug program in the years 2013-2023 was 30% (Figure
5).
The
number of services provided under the B.44 drug program – Treatment of patients
with severe asthma increased proportionally year on year – analogously to the
number of patients in the program. In 2013, the number of services provided
amounted to 1.8 thousand. In 2018, this number increased to 6.2 thousand, and
in 2023 it was already 25 thousand. Similarly, the average rate of increase in
the number of services provided under the drug program in the years 2013-2023
was 30% (Figure 6).
As
the number of patients treated under the drug program and the number of
services provided to them increased, the share of services provided as part of
hospital treatment decreased. In 2013, the share of hospital treatment as part
of services provided under the drug program was over 12%, in 2018 this share
was already 1.2%, and from 2019 this share was less than 1% until 2023 (Figure
7).
Figure 7.
Share of services provided as part of hospitalization under the B.44 drug
program – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in 2013-2023.
In 2013, the value of
services provided under the B.44 drug program – Treatment of patients with
severe asthma amounted to PLN 8.27 million. In the following year, this value
increased to PLN 20.72 million. Until 2018, the value of services in the drug
program was systematically growing, reaching PLN 30 million in 2018. In
subsequent years, an upward trend was observed – PLN 77.99 million in 2021, and
PLN 143.39 million in 2023 (Figure 8).
Figure
8. Value of services provided under drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients
with severe asthma in 2013-2023.
Table 8. Number of patients, number of services provided, share of services provided during hospitalization and the value of services under the drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in 2013-2023.
Year |
Number of patients |
Number of benefits (thou.) |
Percentage of services provided during hospitalization |
Value of benefits (PLN million): Total |
2013 |
247 |
1.8 |
12.3% |
8.27 |
2014 |
351 |
4.4 |
5.1% |
20.72 |
2015 |
400 |
4.8 |
5.8% |
22.71 |
2016 |
439 |
5.5 |
5.7% |
25.39 |
2017 |
503 |
6.2 |
3.3% |
28.86 |
2018 |
764 |
7.3 |
1.2% |
30.08 |
2019 |
1 079 |
11.2 |
1.0% |
45.16 |
2020 |
1 403 |
14.8 |
0.8% |
64.05 |
2021 |
1 852 |
15.2 |
0.7% |
77.99 |
2022 |
2 517 |
19.0 |
0.8% |
106.74 |
2023 |
3 426 |
25.0 |
0.9% |
143.39 |
Table 9. Dynamics of changes in the number of patients, the number of services provided, the share of services provided during hospitalization and the value of services under the drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma year-on-year in 2013-2023.
Detail, comparison |
Number of patients |
Number of benefits (thou.) |
Percentage of services provided during hospitalization |
Value of benefits (PLN million) |
2014/2013 |
42.11% |
144.44% |
-58.54% |
150.54% |
2015/2014 |
13.96% |
9.09% |
13.73% |
9.60% |
2016/2015 |
9.75% |
14.58% |
-1.72% |
11.80% |
2017/2016 |
14.58% |
12.73% |
-42.11% |
13.67% |
2018/2017 |
51.89% |
17.74% |
-63.64% |
4.23% |
2019/2018 |
41.23% |
53.42% |
-16.67% |
50.13% |
average 2019-2013 |
27.86% |
35.62% |
-34.18% |
32.70% |
2020/2019 |
30.03% |
32.14% |
-20.00% |
41.83% |
2021/2020 |
32.00% |
2.70% |
-12.50% |
21.76% |
2022/2021 |
35.91% |
25.00% |
14.29% |
36.86% |
2023/2022 |
36.11% |
31.58% |
12.50% |
34.34% |
average 2023-2019 |
33.49% |
22.23% |
-2.60% |
33.49% |
Average
rate of change 2013-2023 |
30.08% |
30.10% |
-23.01% |
33.02% |
The largest number of patients were
treated under the B.44 drug program – Treatment of patients with severe asthma
in a one-day mode – out of 300 patients in the drug program in 2013, as many as
226 patients were treated in a one-day mode. In 2018, out of 896 patients, 741
patients were treated in a one-day mode. In 2023, the number of patients in a
one-day mode was 2,896, while the number of all patients in the drug program
was 3,835 (Figure 9).
In
2013, there were 4 patients receiving outpatient treatment. In 2018, this
number increased to 89 patients. Since 2019, the number of patients receiving
outpatient treatment has been systematically increasing, reaching 731 patients
in 2023 (Figure 10).
Figure
10. Number of patients treated on an outpatient basis under drug programme B.44
– Treatment of patients with severe asthma in 2013–2023.
The fewest patients were provided with services under the B.44 drug program – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in full hospitalization mode – 70 patients out of 300 in 2023. In 2018, 66 patients, and in 2023, 208 patients (Figure 11).
Figure 11. Number of patients treated as part of full hospitalization under drug program B.44 – Treatment of
patients with severe asthma in 2013-2023.
Table 10. Number of patients under drug programme B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma by admission mode in 2013–2023.
Year |
Number of patients drug program |
Number of patients -
hospitalization |
Number of patients - one-day mode |
Number of patients - outpatient mode |
2013 |
300 |
70 |
226 |
4 |
2014 |
395 |
51 |
339 |
5 |
2015 |
440 |
53 |
380 |
7 |
2016 |
495 |
63 |
428 |
4 |
2017 |
565 |
62 |
499 |
4 |
2018 |
896 |
66 |
741 |
89 |
2019 |
1196 |
92 |
1003 |
101 |
2020 |
1709 |
98 |
1289 |
322 |
2021 |
2007 |
105 |
1523 |
379 |
2022 |
2776 |
139 |
2124 |
513 |
2023 |
3835 |
208 |
2896 |
731 |
Figure 12. Assessment of
the variability of the structure of treatment modes over time.
Analyzing the values of the correlation coefficients, it is possible to conclude about the direction of changes in the structure of admission modes. The changes occurred in the same direction for the outpatient mode and the full hospitalization mode – the convergence can be assessed at an average level of 52%. An inverse relationship of variability was observed in the case of full hospitalization and one-day mode, and one-day mode and outpatient mode. The compliance was assessed at the level of 98% and 67%, respectively. While the hospitalization mode is quite stable, for about 60-70% of the share, it will be noticed that the share of the feature in the total structure decreases in favor of an increase in one-day admissions, for which the coefficient of variation was noted at the level of Vs=34.29%. Over the analyzed period, the number of one-day admissions was doubled (Table 11).
Outpatient mode |
One day mode |
Hospitalization |
1 |
-0.67 |
0.52 |
-0.67 |
1 |
-0.98 |
0.52 |
-0.98 |
1 |
The
share of patients in full hospitalization under the drug program B.44 –
Treatment of patients with severe asthma amounted to 72% in 2013 and remained
at a similar level until 2018. In subsequent years, the share of hospitalized
patients decreased – in 2019 it amounted to 68%, and in 2023 already 61%. The
share of patients treated in outpatient mode amounted to 17% in 2013, 16% in
2018, and increased in subsequent years, up to 26% in 2023. In turn, the share
of patients covered by full hospitalization under the drug program amounted to
12% in 2013 and remained at this level until 2017. In 2018 it increased to 14%.
By 2022 this share amounted to an average of 16%. In 2023, however, a decrease
in the share of hospitalized patients was observed to 13% (Figure 13).
Figure 13. Share of the number of patients by the level of the structure of admission modes under the drug programme B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in 2013-2023.
Table 12. Dynamics of changes in the number of patients by the level of the structure of admission modes under the drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in 2013-2023.
Detail,
comparison |
Number of patients drug program |
Number of patients - full hospitalization |
Number of patients - one day mode |
Number of patients - outpatient mode |
2014/2013 |
31.67% |
-27.14% |
50.00% |
25.00% |
2015/2014 |
11.39% |
3.92% |
12.09% |
40.00% |
2016/2015 |
12.50% |
18.87% |
12.63% |
-42.86% |
2017/2016 |
14.14% |
-1.59% |
16.59% |
0.00% |
2018/2017 |
58.58% |
6.45% |
48.50% |
2125.00% |
2019/2018 |
33.48% |
39.39% |
35.36% |
13.48% |
average 2019-2013 |
25.92% |
4.66% |
28.19% |
71.28% |
2020/2019 |
42.89% |
6.52% |
28.51% |
218.81% |
2021/2020 |
17.44% |
7.14% |
18.15% |
17.70% |
2022/2021 |
38.32% |
32.38% |
39.46% |
35.36% |
2023/2022 |
38.15% |
49.64% |
36.35% |
42.50% |
average 2023-2019 |
33.82% |
22.62% |
30.35% |
64.02% |
average
2023-2013 |
29.02% |
11.51% |
29.05% |
68.34% |
Number of services provided under the drug program
B.44 Treatment of patients with severe asthma
As part of full hospitalization, the number of services provided under the drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma amounted to 1,783,000 in 2013. In the following year, the number of services increased by over 400% to 4,362,000 services. In subsequent years, the number of services grew systematically. In 2019, an increase in the number of services of over 54% was observed compared to the previous year. In 2023, the number of services amounted to 25,034,000 (Figure 14).
The largest number of services in the drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma were provided as part of the one-day procedure. In 2013, 1,561 thousand services were provided in this mode. In 2018, the number of services provided as part of the one-day procedure increased to 6,799 thousand services. In 2023, the number of services provided amounted to 20,608 thousand (Figure 15).
In outpatient mode, under the drug program B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma, 4 thousand services were provided in 2013, 398 thousand services in 2018 and 4,200 thousand services in 2023 (Figure 16).
The
number of services provided as part of full hospitalization was characterized
by a downward trend in the years covered by the analysis. The number of
services amounted to 218 thousand in 2013. In the following years, this number
decreased until 2016. In 2016, it amounted to 314 thousand. In 2018, only 83
thousand services were provided. In the following years, the number of services
provided as part of full hospitalization increased, and in 2023 it amounted to
226 thousand services (Figure 17).
Figure 17.
Number of services provided in full hospitalization mode under drug program
B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Table 13. Number of services provided as part of hospitalisation and the value of services under the drug programme B.44 – Treatment of patients with severe asthma in the years 2013-2023, thou.
Year |
Number of patients drug program |
Number of patients - full hospitalization |
Number of patients - one day mode |
Number of patients - outpatient mode |
2013 |
1783 |
218 |
1561 |
4 |
2014 |
4362 |
221 |
4124 |
17 |
2015 |
4834 |
281 |
4519 |
34 |
2016 |
5471 |
314 |
5124 |
33 |
2017 |
6232 |
203 |
6005 |
24 |
2018 |
7280 |
83 |
6799 |
398 |
2019 |
11211 |
108 |
10351 |
752 |
2020 |
14766 |
115 |
12464 |
2187 |
2021 |
15163 |
111 |
12381 |
2671 |
2022 |
18962 |
150 |
15626 |
3186 |
2023 |
25034 |
226 |
20608 |
4200 |
Year |
Number of patients drug program |
Number of patients - full hospitalization |
Number of patients - one day mode |
Number of patients - outpatient mode |
2014/2013 |
144.64% |
1.38% |
164.19% |
325.00% |
2015/2014 |
10.82% |
27.15% |
9.58% |
100.00% |
2016/2015 |
13.18% |
11.74% |
13.39% |
-2.94% |
2017/2016 |
13.91% |
-35.35% |
17.19% |
-27.27% |
2018/2017 |
16.82% |
-59.11% |
13.22% |
1558.33% |
2019/2018 |
54.00% |
30.12% |
52.24% |
88.94% |
average 2019-2013 |
35.86% |
-11.05% |
37.07% |
139.35% |
2020/2019 |
31.71% |
6.48% |
20.41% |
190.82% |
2021/2020 |
2.69% |
-3.48% |
-0.67% |
22.13% |
2022/2021 |
25.05% |
35.14% |
26.21% |
19.28% |
2023/2022 |
32.02% |
50.67% |
31.88% |
31.83% |
average 2023-2019 |
22.24% |
20.27% |
18.79% |
53.73% |
Average
2023-2013 |
30.24% |
0.36% |
29.44% |
100.50% |
Analysis of
the benefits of the Health Insurance Institution for incapacity for work
resulting from the medical problem of bronchial asthma, defined by the ICD-10
main diagnosis codes: asthma J45 and status asthmaticus J46
Total Social Insurance
Institution benefits for incapacity for work resulting from the medical problem
of bronchial asthma for the years 2019-2023
The
Social Insurance Institution expenditure
on benefits for incapacity for work resulting from the medical problem of
bronchial asthma, defined by the ICD-10 main diagnosis codes: asthma J45
(entire group) and status asthmaticus J46 (entire group) for the years
2019-2023 was analyzed.
In the years 2019-2023, a stable level of total benefits for incapacity for work resulting from the medical problem of bronchial asthma, defined by the ICD-10 main diagnosis codes: asthma J45 (entire group) and status asthmaticus J46 (entire group) was recorded from PLN 193,241.50 thousand in 2019 to PLN 200,469.70 thousand in 2023 (Figure 18).
Table 15. Social Insurance Institution benefits for incapacity for work resulting from the medical problem of bronchial asthma, specified by the ICD-10 main diagnosis codes: asthma J45 (entire group) and status asthmaticus J46 (entire group) for the years 2019-2023, PLN, thou.
Specification |
Total |
Disability pensions |
Social pensions |
Absence due to illness |
Rehabilitation benefit |
Therapeutic rehabilitation |
|
amount in thousands PLN |
|||||||
2019 |
TOTAL |
193 241,50 |
123 370,70 |
6 829,70 |
54 842,90 |
5 808,80 |
2 389,30 |
J45 |
Asthma |
192 620,40 |
122 914,30 |
6 829,70 |
54 693,80 |
5 798,30 |
2 384,30 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
621,1 |
456,4 |
- |
149,1 |
10,5 |
5 |
2020 |
TOTAL |
240 626,10 |
120 718,70 |
7 137,50 |
104 469,70 |
7 638,90 |
661,2 |
J45 |
Asthma |
239 824,90 |
120 154,50 |
7 137,50 |
104 257,30 |
7 616,90 |
658,7 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
801,2 |
564,2 |
- |
212,4 |
22 |
2,5 |
2021 |
TOTAL |
200 695,80 |
117 738,40 |
7 255,10 |
67 225,90 |
7 896,10 |
580,3 |
J45 |
Asthma |
200 003,10 |
117 170,90 |
7 255,10 |
67 100,70 |
7 896,10 |
580,3 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
692,7 |
567,5 |
- |
125,2 |
- |
- |
2022 |
TOTAL |
192 301,40 |
117 270,40 |
7 345,60 |
59 166,50 |
6 361,10 |
2 157,70 |
J45 |
Asthma |
191 490,40 |
116 676,00 |
7 345,60 |
58 970,40 |
6 340,70 |
2 157,70 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
811 |
594,4 |
- |
196,1 |
20,4 |
- |
2023 |
TOTAL |
200 469,70 |
124 356,90 |
8 173,70 |
58 889,60 |
7 118,70 |
1 930,90 |
J45 |
Asthma |
199 976,40 |
124 014,30 |
8 173,70 |
58 738,80 |
7 118,70 |
1 930,90 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
493,3 |
342,6 |
- |
150,8 |
- |
- |
Number of persons insured with
the Social Insurance Institution who were issued a medical certificate for
bronchial asthma (J45) and Status asthmaticus (J46) at least once in the years
2019-2024
In the years
2019-2024, the number of people insured with ZUS who were issued a medical
certificate for bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) at least
once in the years 2019-2024 remained at a constant level. In 2019, there were
37,964 people with asthma and 192 people with status asthmaticus, while in
2024, the numbers were 37,543 and 156 people, respectively (Table 16).
Table 16. Number of persons insured with the Social Insurance Institution who were issued a medical certificate for bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) at least once in the years 2019-2024
Disease entities |
Number of people |
|||||
2019 |
2020 |
2021 |
2022 |
2023 |
2024 |
|
Bronchial asthma (J45) |
37 964 |
45 562 |
32 845 |
34 676 |
34 612 |
37 543 |
Status asthmaticus (J46) |
192 |
170 |
150 |
145 |
146 |
156 |
Figure 20. Number of persons insured with ZUS who were issued a medical certificate for bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) at least once in the years 2019-2024
Number of absence due to
bronchial asthma (J45) and Status asthmaticus (J46) in 2012-2024
In the years 2012-2024, a decrease in the number of absence days due to bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) was noted. In terms of the number of sick leave days due to bronchial asthma (J45), there was a decrease from 735,410 days in 2012 to 532,352 days in 2024. Therefore, a 28% decrease was noted (203,058 fewer sick leave days) comparing 2012 to 2024 (Figure 21).
In terms of the number of days of
sickness absence due to status asthmaticus (J46), there was a decrease from
7,919 days in 2012 to 1,602 days in 2024. Therefore, an 80% decrease was
recorded (6,317 days of sickness absence less) when comparing 2012 to 2024
(Figure 22).
Figure
22. Number of days of absence due to status asthmaticus in 2012-2024
Table 17. Number of days of sickness absence due to bronchial asthma (J45) and status asthmaticus (J46) in 2012-2024
Year |
ICD10 |
Disease entity |
Number of days of sickness absence |
2024 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
532 352 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
1 602 |
|
2023 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
513 138 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
1 518 |
|
2022 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
550 028 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
1 763 |
|
2021 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
618 561 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
1 521 |
|
2020 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
1 098 859 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
2 547 |
|
2019 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
664 711 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
2 272 |
|
2018 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
718 978 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
4 491 |
|
2017 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
755 612 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
6 708 |
|
2016 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
741 095 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
6 355 |
|
2015 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
758 591 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
6 822 |
|
2014 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
713 979 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
6 464 |
|
2013 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
748 474 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
6 444 |
|
2012 |
J45 |
Bronchial asthma |
735 410 |
J46 |
Status asthmaticus |
7 919 |
4. Discussion
Systemic
aspects of bronchial asthma are primarily regular and cyclical assessment of
the delivery of health value, expressed by the ratio of health effects to total
costs incurred, taking into account the patient's quality of life (QoL, PROM,
PREM). In the case of achieving remission (value of remission) or alleviating
the course of this disease, it is important to reduce steroid doses, inhibit
exacerbations requiring expensive hospitalizations and the quality of life of
patients. The key to this process is the analysis of actual data from clinical
practice (RWD), NFZ and ZUS data. A very important indicator is the
reimbursement access to drugs registered in the European Union included in the
current therapeutic standards.
Thanks
to access to effective treatment within the framework of pharmacy reimbursement
and the B.44 drug program, patients with severe asthma do not have/or have
fewer exacerbations, are not/or are hospitalized less often. According to data
from the National Health Fund, the number of hospitalizations has decreased by
half in the last decade due to effective treatment. The value of reimbursement
of hospitalizations due to asthma of adult patients carried out in hospital
treatment, excluding hospitalizations under the drug program and
hospitalizations started and ended on the same day, remained at a constant
level. Data on the effectiveness of biological drugs show a remission rate of
approx. 70%, and a drop-out rate of several percent. Considering the priority
of optimizing the healthcare system in Poland towards an outpatient model of
care, the number of patients with severe asthma treated under the drug program
should be increased.
The recommended model of care for patients with bronchial asthma is coordinated care, i.e. a system based on cooperation between a primary care physician, an allergist and pulmonologist, a nurse, an educator and the patient. The goals of coordinated care are to improve the continuity of care, reduce system costs and improve the effects of treatment and the quality of life of the patient. The elements of coordinated care for a patient with bronchial asthma are:
- Patient education: self-control, correct inhalation technique.
- Action plan: description of symptoms of deterioration and therapeutic recommendations.
- Fast diagnostic and therapeutic path: primary care–specialist–hospital.
- Telemedicine: contact with a doctor and nurse via e-consultation.
- Therapeutic team: joint documentation and therapeutic decisions.
5. Conclusions
Since introduction of the first medicinal products for financing under the asthma treatment drug programme in 2013, the following has been observed:
- Decrease in the number of patients registered for hospital treatment at the level of: -2.79% (-2.27% pre-pandemic period, -3.57% post-pandemic period), similar negative dynamics are observed in outpatient care and primary healthcare.
- This means better disease control in patients, a conclusion confirmed by the stable and similar distribution of the number of patients, taking into account the mode of admission to hospital.
- The impact of the pandemic on the number of patients with asthma (not related to COVID infection) is clearly visible; after the acute phase of the pandemic (2020-2021), an increase in the number of patients is observed, but their number does not return to the previous level, which is explained by effective therapy under the drug program.
In the scope of Social Insurance Institution benefits for incapacity for work due to bronchial asthma and status asthmaticus:
- In the years 2019-2023, a stable level of total benefits for incapacity for work resulting from the medical problem of bronchial asthma, defined by the ICD-10 main diagnosis codes: asthma J45 (the entire group) and status asthmaticus J46 (the entire group) was recorded from PLN 193,241.50 thousand in 2019 to PLN 200,469.70 thousand in 2023.
- In the years 2019-2024, the number of people insured with Social Insurance Institution who were issued a medical certificate for bronchial asthma (J45) and Status asthmaticus (J46) at least once in the years 2019-2024 remained at a constant level. In 2019, there were 37,964 people with asthma and 192 people with Status asthmaticus, while in 2024 there were 37,543 people with asthma and 156 people with Status asthmaticus.
- In the years 2012-2024, a decrease in the number of sick leave days due to bronchial asthma (J45) and Status asthmaticus (J46) was noted. In terms of the number of days of sickness absence due to bronchial asthma (J45), there was a decrease from 735,410 days in 2012 to 532,352 days in 2024. This means a 28% decrease (203,058 days of sickness absence less) when comparing 2012 to 2024. In terms of the number of days of sickness absence due to Status asthmaticus (J46), there was a dramatic decrease from 7,919 days in 2012 to 1,602 days in 2024. This means a 80% decrease (6,317 days of sickness absence less) when comparing 2012 to 2024.
Conflict
of Interest and Influence Statement:
Publication
was supported by Unique Work.
- Prof. Jahnz-Różyk K. Lecture on the occasion of World Asthma Day (PAP). [cited 24.04.2025]. Available from: https://pap-mediaroom.pl/zdrowie-i-styl-zycia/konferencja-prasowa-pt-swiatowy-dzien-astmy-optymalna-terapia-astmy-szansa-na
- Global Initiative for Asthma. Global Strategy for Asthma Management and Prevention, 2024. Updated May 2024. [cited 24.04.2025] Available from: www.ginasthma.org
- Data from National Health Fund (NFZ) received as part of access to public information.
- Data from Social Insurance Institution (ZUS) received as part of access to public information.